How to balance use and visitation
A few months ago we had an adventure hiking to the end of the world just to see a 1000-year-old pot sitting serenely in place somewhere in San Juan County. Many people are upset that I would post a picture of the pot or even talk about it.
I have visited what I consider sacred sites all over the world. Here in SJC I have hiked to many remote places and honestly some of my most spiritual experiences were in places without names, were not on a map, and I did not find on the internet.
I have seen thousands of pots in museums and secret government collections. The BLM’s Cerberus collection holds nearly 102,000 items, including 1,600 ceramic objects, over 350 woven items, thousands of pieces of jewelry and thousands of ground stone and projectile points.
Seeing all these in the inventoried sorted neatly catalogued sterile climate-controlled setting elicited nothing but sadness. There was no jaw dropping spiritual soul expanding moment like I had looking at that pot sitting in the sunlight as it had done for a thousand years.
So how do we protect a lone intact beautiful pot. No curated display can capture the beauty of that pot stubbornly reminding us of a time and people centuries ago. A people living in harmony with a harsh land. One mistake and you fall to your death.
One drought and you lose your crops and don’t make it through the year. There were enemies roaming. And yet, in one of the harshest environments on planet earth people were trying to raise a family, kids got sick, and they were hungry during the lean years. These people were part of a delicate and complicated society.
The juxtaposition of 5 million visitors crawling all over the Acropolis or me enjoying a beautiful pot somewhere in SJC is mind bending. After wading through the mire of thousands of tourists visiting established destinations, it begs the question “How do you visit these places and not ruin the resource and degrade the experience?”
You can open the gates and let the masses swarm about. Not pretty, not sustainable, and not a good experience for the visitor. The very reason for visiting gets lost in the commercialism of t-shirts and food trucks.
You might be able to limit the visitation or use to some sustainable level. I think of BLM’s attempt to do this at The Wave (lottery) and Moon House (limit group size & visits). There are many places where demand far exceeds the ability of the resource to survive unmetered use.
You can try to lock it all up in remote hard to access wilderness and monuments effectively making an exclusive playground that only that the young and fit with lots of time can explore at their leisure. This eliminates the public at large, the elderly, and those with limited mobility.
Let me just state my position. I believe that public lands are for the public. The public includes soccer moms and their kids, hunters, cowboys, campers, mountain bikers, miners, boaters, hikers, oil and gas people, environmentalists, wilderness and monument advocates, Native Americans, and all others with an inclination to visit their public lands.
I want as many people to fall in love with their public lands as possible because what you come to love… you come to treasure and protect. Protect does NOT mean lock it all up, it means becoming a good steward of the land and resources so future generations will be able to experience the thrill of seeing a lone pot sitting serenely where it has for thousands of years.
I have always believed that the history of San Juan County is a history of conflict between Native Americans, Mormon pioneers, Spanish explorers and their posterity, cowboys, miners, and environmentalists; mostly in that order. Each group is convinced that their use of the land is the highest and best use for this beautiful land that we all love.
And although the story of SJC is framed by conflict, we have much in common. We love the red rocks, the remoteness, ruggedness, the large open spaces, and the serenity of the desert.
A baby calf in springtime reminds me of the hopes and prayers of farmers and ranchers. A spotted fawn on wobbly legs reminds us of the fragility of life itself.
Catching a glimpse of the prankster coyote or bashful bobcat or circling buzzards tells the story of death in this harsh country. Not every cute fawn becomes a magnificent buck. Life and death; the circle of life all around us. All of this makes it beautiful and cherished to us.
How do we fit in? How do we honor our past but work for our future. Are we so elitist that we believe we are the only ones that should be able to visit our public lands? Multiple use and sustained yield does not mean all uses on every acre of land. It does require balance, harmony, cooperation, and compromise. If one group gets everything it wants, we all lose! If none of us get anything we want, we all lose.
We may love the resources and land but suffocate it and destroy it by too much visitation or we are derelict and don’t become wise stewards of limited fragile valuable resources. We all lose.
I am not sure of the answer. I am probably not smart enough to even think of all the right questions. But we have a great legacy in public lands that will require our best thinking, our most unselfish disposition, our strategic planning, and we must ponder about things bigger than ourselves.
In this time of conflict and hate those are values not always embraced. A lone pot can be a reminder that we still have a chance to make good decisions and balance all that we love about this land.
