Panel looks at future of uranium cleanup on Navajo at Energy Fuels open house
As part of the Energy Fuels 2025 “Critically Important” open house held on October 14-15, the company invited representatives from the Navajo Nation to participate in a panel entitled Building a Responsible Energy Future – Tribal, Federal and Industry Partnerships.
Carlyle Begay, a former Republican Arizona State Senator and moderator of the panel shared that the company has built a relationship of trust with the Navajo Nation.
“Unfortunately mining in particular within the Navajo Nation is replete with a lot of tragic actions. A lot of missed opportunities, a lot of things that unfortunately can't change and a lot of our communities in the Navajo Nation still live with that legacy and I appreciate the leadership of Energy Fuels recognizing that that relationship between an energy company and a tribal nation builds on the foundation of trust.”
Begay says that trust was built over an eight month negotiation period. When the Pinyon Plain mine north of the Grand Canyon re-opened Energy Fuels brought trucks hauling ore from that mine across the Navajo Nation up to the White Mesa Mill in San Juan County.
Navajo Nation law prohibits transportation of uranium across its sovereign lands, however the use of federal highways complicates the matter. The company and the Navajo Nation held discussions about the transportation and were able to come to an agreement in January 2025.
In addition to following federal US Department of Transportation requirements the company also agreed to limit transportation to specific routes and hours of the day, observe spelled out emergency response procedures, notices and reporting requirements along with additional trainings, insurance and license requirements.
The partners further explained that the conversations around the transport agreement also evolved to how the company could aid in abandoned uranium mine cleanups across the Navajo Nation. Begay explained.
“Our communities and our people still live and endure that legacy today. There are over 500 abandoned uranium mines throughout the Navajo Nation and it's a legacy that we're still trying to address and we're on the cusp of at the moment of forging a new public private partnership that allows us as a Navajo Nation to address decades long issues related to cleanup and doing it responsibly in partnership with not only Energy Fuels but there other private companies that are assisting.”
Energy Fuels Senior Vice President of Marketing & Corporate Development Curtis Moore explained during those first few meetings the company just listened and tried to understand concerns.
“Try to get to the heart of the issues here. We did constantly hear about (the abandoned mines) and we've been trying to get involved in this for a decade now operating to be helpful and the time may be coming where we can be helpful.”
In an earlier speech Moore mentioned the agreement and the work to offer some aid in the Navajo Nation uranium clean-up is one of the things he’s most proud of.
“Even though Energy Fuels had nothing to do with it, the industry does have this legacy. There's people suffering today from that legacy that happened many, many decades ago. They have contaminated groundwater or they have illness and we have the ability and technology to get it moving.”
The Navajo Nation is exploring using a separation process at scale, the process is called high pressure slurry ablation. In basic terms the process uses technology to hit this soil with high pressure water to separate uranium from sand. The process would end up with three streams.
One stream would contain an upgraded ore with uranium in it, Energy Fuels would receive that ore, run it through the mill to recover uranium and put it into the nuclear industry.
Another stream would be a clean stream, leaving materials that meet the appropriate cleanup standards to be put back on the Navajo Nation.
The final stream would contain contaminated materials that would be placed in a repository. In August 2025 the Navajo Nation Council Resource and Development Committee received a report from the Eastern Navajo Land Commission and the Navajo Environmental Protection Agency proposing Ambrosia Lake Valley in New Mexico as a potential uranium waste repository.
Moore explained the White Mesa Mill could be a resource for receiving the higher grade ore to pull recoverable uranium from the cleanup.
While high pressure slurry ablation hasn’t been tested at a large scale yet, there is hope that it could help with the cleanup process.
With nearly 500 abandoned mines and millions of tons of contaminated soil and dirt the project will certainly take some time.
Moore added it’ll take a lot of effort, time and money for the cleanup.
“So, they're trying to figure out, is there a way we can do the clean-ups faster in a little bit less intrusive of a way that's just as effective by using some new technologies and we're just trying to be helpful in that.”
Dan Moquin works for the Navajo Department of Justice speaking on the panel he shared the process has bipartisan support including Arizona Democratic Senator Mark Kelly and Wyoming Republican Senator John Barrasso.
“Obviously ideologically in different places but they both are practical, reasonable people that can see good technology and see we need to utilize it.”
Navajo Nation Council representative and Chair of the Natural Resource and Development Committee Brenda Jesus also spoke about the recognition of traditional perspectives including offerings when taking from Mother Earth.
“At the end of the day it's prosperity not just to the Navajo Nation through the revenue stream that comes back to Navajo Nation but it's also prosperity to the company that is extracting and taking this off and utilizing it. Whether we're heating up homes or lighting up homes or businesses across this great country.”
The remediation efforts could also offer potential job opportunities for the Navajo people and a possible source of revenue if the economics of recovering the upgraded ore prove viable.
Currently, billions of dollars are available through settlements to take on the cleanup.
Executive Director of the Easter Navajo Land Commission, Honorable Leonard Tsosie spoke about the commission he works with passing a resolution asking that the waste be taken off the reservation, and exploring the ablation method but noted there’s been challenges working with federal agencies.
“There's this trust relationship between Indian tribes and the federal government and the US Department of Energy is part of the federal government and they're supposed to listen to their beneficiary as a trustee. But lately we haven't had really good conversations with them. And so the better conversations have developed with Energy Fuels and others and I think that lends itself to resolving a problem in this case trying to resolve the problem of what to do with abandoned mining.”
Moore also recognized that it's the Navajo Nation leadership that is leading out on the cleanup.
“We're just a small part of it, right? We're trying to be helpful in terms of being the repository for let's say the highest grade material, right? That does have recoverable quantities of uranium in it that they could recover and put into the nuclear industry.
Depending on how the ultimate economics of it all work out, you know, it could be a source of revenue for the Navajo Nation.”
Moore added that details have to be fleshed out including testing to scale but they remain optimistic about the process.
Moquin was involved in the negotiation process as part of the transportation agreement between the tribe and company, he noted both parties were respectful and professional. Moquin added that working with private partners like Energy Fuels has been helpful when compared to some of the challenges working with bureaucracies regarding the issue.
Moore also noted the cleanup would allow the industry itself to move forward.
“This was stuff that happened many decades ago, a totally different scientific and regulatory environment and all that. Different geopolitics, everything was different. which we don't have today and it left a mess.I don't think they did it intentionally. I think they didn't know and it was a cold war. I don't fault the people that did that, but people are living with the consequences today.”
Moore explained even if the High-Pressure Slurry Ablation does not work at scale, the White Mesa Mill is still equipped to help in some capacity as the Navajo Nation leads on the cleanup of abandoned uranium mines on Navajoland.
